DC judge denies another effort to derail Michael Mann’s defamation lawsuit

Superior Court of the District of Columbia

Superior Court of the District of Columbia

Moving forward to the discovery stage of Michael Mann’s defamation lawsuit against the National Review and the Competitive Enterprise Institute was expedited when District of Columbia Superior Court judge Weisberg on September 12 denied yet another motion by the defendants that would have created a procedural delay. If the defendants’ are hoping that having a new judge on the case will bring a very different viewpoint, his first procedural ruling doesn’t support it.

Text of the judge’s ruling: Order Denying Defendants’ Joint Motion for Interlocutory Certification of the Court’s July 19, 2013 Orders under D.C. Code § 11-721


Although this case undoubtedly involves complex and important issues at the intersection of the First Amendment and the common law of defamation as applied to public figures, there is not “a substantial ground for a difference of opinion” on the controlling questions of law. The [Court’s July 19, 2013, order denying defendants’ motion to dismiss] represents an application of relatively settled law to the facts as articulated in the complaint, and a conclusion that plaintiff has alleged enough to move his case forward to the discovery stage.

Judge Weisberg also prodded the case along with this footnote:

3 As an aside, the court observes that the litigation of this matter will be as expensive as the parties choose to make it. It appears that most of the relevant facts are well known. If the parties can get through the discovery stage with a minimum of acrimony, they should be able to advance the case to the summary judgment phase in relatively short order.

So, let’s see what the discovery stage brings out.

Earlier CSW posts on this case:

Judge denies National Review’s Motion to Reconsider ruling in Michael Mann’s defamation case (August 30)

Michael Mann v. National Review et al. defamation lawsuit – new Plaintiff’s briefs (August 19)

DC Court affirms Michael Mann’s right to proceed in defamation lawsuit against National Review and CEI (July 19)

This entry was posted in Attacks on Climate Science and Scientists. Bookmark the permalink.